A preface: I occasionally look at other reviews before writing my own because – let’s face it – sometimes we miss things during a two-hour film, and it helps to check around. This time, however, I haven’t missed anything. Of the reviews I’ve read, about 95% have been very negative. Of those 95%, about 100% are wrong.
To watch The Book Thief is like assembling a lovely but mysterious puzzle. Minutes, like puzzle pieces, are introduced and put together, a few here and there, more there and here. The pieces themselves are pretty and interesting but not spectacular on their own. Not until the entire puzzle is finished, not until the final minutes are clicked into place, not until the box is empty and all 1,000 parts are assembled, can you be fully aware of the beauty that is The Book Thief.
If you never cry in a film, then it could be argued you have neither a heart nor the ability to appreciate film. If you never cry in a film, then you have no right to review, critique, or even watch film. If you never cry in a film, then please don’t waste your time buying a ticket to this one. I watched about an hour and fifty minutes of The Book Thief wavering between frowns, smiles, and tension. Nothing too far in any direction, but the remaining twenty minutes drained my emotions as few films ever have. As beautiful as it was, the story had one confusing element that might have worked magic in the book, but in the film was not quite on the mark, and that’s how the film begins.
Death sporadically narrates the story. He opens the first shot, letting us know that one day, we are all going to die, just a matter of time. Death also tells us that occasionally, he finds reason to watch and get closer to certain people. It is at that moment that Liesel (Sophie Nélisse) is with her mother and brother on a train from Russia to Germany, where her mother intends to give up her two children for adoption. Death, however, has other plans and takes the boy’s life. This is our introduction to mortality and its consequences.
One consequence is that Liesel is now alone when turned over to her new parents, Hans and Rosa Hubermann (Geoffrey Rush and Emily Watson), an older couple who have arranged to adopt two children. When Rosa learns that the boy has died, she’s more upset about the stipend they won’t receive than the loss of a boy’s life and, more important, a younger brother to a 12-year old sister who is now alone in a strange land.
Rosa appears rather gritty and harsh, but Hans lets Liesel know immediately that he will be a father, friend, teacher, and – when needed – her clown and servant. She knows this immediately when he refers to her as “your majesty,” as he escorts her from the car to their quaint home in a German village. While Hans paints houses, Rosa does the laundry of more well-to-do folk, like the mayor and his wife. They attempt to bother nobody and just live as a happy family in their blissfully ignorant corner of 1939 amid the Nazi rise to power.
Through no fault of her own, Liesel cannot read and on her first day of school is bullied, until she not only fights back but beats the crap out of the bully. Instant street cred. Hans is not the greatest reader, but he knows it’s a key to education and happiness. He finds what books he can, and together they read and learn with great excitement.
One of Liesel’s first friends is Rudy, the perfect depiction of what Hitler considers, well, perfect. Athletic, smart, blue eyes, and “hair like lemons,” as Liesel puts it. Rudy likes to run, and run he does, while admiring the likes of track star Jesse Owens so much that he blackens his face while pretending to run as Owens did in the Berlin Olympics of ’36. After a reprimand and bathtub scrubbing of the black off the boy’s face, he asks his father why he can’t pretend to be Owens. “Because I said so.” The practice of “shut up and listen” reaches beyond just a boy in a bathtub.
In school, the children are indoctrinated as little Nazis, wearing the swastika on their brown shirts while singing praise to their mother land. A national celebration for “Der Fuhrer’s” birthday doesn’t seem unusual. However, when book burnings are billed as an intellectual cleansing, Liesel and Hans begin to take notice of how the new Germany is affecting the small folk. Following “kristallnacht,” Hans is asked to hide Max, a Jewish boy, in his home. Years ago, Max’s father gave his own life to save Hans in World War I. Now, Hans must repay the favor and hides the boy. Liesel now has a grave secret to keep.
When Liesel and Hans run out of books – or, when too many books have been burned – she creeps into the mayor’s home and “borrows” books from his wife’s library. Thus, the “book thief.” But it’s not about just stealing or borrowing books. It’s about the life they bring, literally and figuratively, as neighbors begin to spy on neighbors, soldiers check basements, and storm troopers parade those with yellow stars through the streets.
Geoffrey Rush (Pirates of the Caribbean, The King’s Speech) will make you wish he was your grandfather. Although his accent drifts from Australian to British to German, it makes no difference because he says more with a wink and a smile than most of us can say with a fully charged laptop. Emily Watson (War Horse, Anna Karenina), who deserves a nomination for Best Supporting Actress, carries Rosa from monster to maven, and no scene illustrates that better than when she visits Liesel in school. As for Sophie Nélisse as Liesel, where to begin? She appeared in two foreign films before this and won the Canadian version of an Oscar for Best Supporting Actress in 2012. I can’t think of another child her age giving such a performance as she does here with such a serious subject. Her gigantic eyes fill with wonder, fear, and hope each time we see her. All we can do now is watch where she goes from here and assume she goes nowhere but up.
One criticism I read about The Book Thief was of the ending, referring to it as “schmaltzy” when we learn of Liesel’s future fate. Let’s keep perspective and remember the original story was categorized as “young adult.” The film needs to be judged similarly. Another criticism was that it only glossed over the rise of the Nazis and the Holocaust. I don’t accept that because this story is about children in a village far from the prison camps. They didn’t know of the Holocaust, not yet. They didn’t know what Hitler was doing throughout Europe. Is it fair to expect people to take action against something of which they have no knowledge? Director Brian Percival (Downton Abbey) has been criticized for not using this story to show the Holocaust in the way that Schindler’s List handled it. This is not a Holocaust story.
The Book Thief is a story about a girl who is an outcast in more ways than one and searches, much like the rest of us, for common ground on which to be accepted by those around her. And I can’t expect it to be done any better. Teacher gives it an A.
20 thoughts on ““The Book Thief” – can’t wait to read the book”
Hello Rich. Long time, no seehear I’ve only read the first few sentences of your review. I was worried you’d give away the plot so left off, but what I read was enough to make we want to read the book and watch the film. That’s some talent you have. Ann
Thank you very much for the compliment. I set up the plot, but I don’t think I gave anything away. However, safe to say you will enjoy it anyway, regardless of how much further you read.
I will certainly cry … I’m very good at that! 🙂
Well done, Rich. I think now that I’ll see the movie first, then read the book. Just one thing so you’ll know it’s really me. Errant apostrophe alert here: “Hans let’s Liesel.” 🙂
thanks miss. as if i didn’t know it was you. silly.
the book was one of my favorites ever. i’m quite sure you’ll love it.
me too also. thanks.
I will definitely check this out!
great. let me know what you think of it.
Sounds great, especially as it seems to offer us an insight into the lives of simple people just getting on with it as the events in their country roll over them. Must put it on a watch list and look out the book.
i will be picking up the book soon. thanks for stopping by and i hope you enjoy the movie as much as i did.
It hasn’t arrived here in Oz yet, so it’s on the Watch List I keep on my phone so I don’t forget the name!
I haven’t seen the movie yet. We just started reading the book in my 8th grade class this week, so I am not quite ready to spoil the sense of discovery that occurs as one reads the book. The students are begging to see the movie, so I am glad to see that it is worth seeing. The language is so beautiful in the book that I am curious to see what happens in the movie.
As one who has both read the book and seen the movie, I couldn’t agree more with your review.
There are scads of Holocaust books and movies. Enough gore and grit to go around for another century. But “The Book Thief” tells another side of it. I appreciated that.
I wondered, before I saw the movie, how they would handle the narrator. Throughout the book you read his musings and asides. I thought they did very well. As for the “schmaltzy” ending…it followed the book to a T.
I, too, was a blubbering mass at the end, although my tears started earlier than the last 20 minutes.
Well done review, sir and I agree 100%.
i will give the book a go very soon. my tendency – which is not popular and unintentional – is to see a movie first and then read the book. too often we finish a book, wait for the movie, and then we think, “oh, there was so much that was left out of the movie. also, i wish there was more. i wish it continued.”
either way, book-movie or movie-book, you already know the ending the second time. so that point is irrelevant. one thing that slows down readers is having to get through early exposition to understand characters, know who is who, and figure out where the story is going. but with movie-book, that “problem” is erased. also, with movie-book, you get extra. you get more scenes and more moments that were left out of the movie. so it’s almost like getting deleted scenes, or an extended version of the movie.
either way, i’m glad you had the same experience in the theater, blubbering included.
Thank you. I have read many of the bad reviews, now I have read yours. I trust you more. I will see the movie now.
thanks very much for having such trust. i’m sure you won’t be disappointed, and please let me know your feelings after you see it.
Reblogged this on Pen-to-Paper and commented:
I LOVE THE BOOK AND CAN’T WAIT TO SEE THE MOVIE!